A Storm over This Court

Law, Politics, and Supreme Court Decision Making in Brown v. Board of Education

Nonfiction, Reference & Language, Law, Legal History
Cover of the book A Storm over This Court by Jeffrey D. Hockett, University of Virginia Press
View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart
Author: Jeffrey D. Hockett ISBN: 9780813933757
Publisher: University of Virginia Press Publication: May 24, 2013
Imprint: University of Virginia Press Language: English
Author: Jeffrey D. Hockett
ISBN: 9780813933757
Publisher: University of Virginia Press
Publication: May 24, 2013
Imprint: University of Virginia Press
Language: English

On the way to offering a new analysis of the basis of the Supreme Court’s iconic decision in Brown v. Board of Education, Jeffrey Hockett critiques an array of theories that have arisen to explain it and Supreme Court decision making generally. Drawing upon justices’ books, articles, correspondence, memoranda, and draft opinions, A Storm over This Court demonstrates that the puzzle of Brown’s basis cannot be explained by any one theory.

Borrowing insights from numerous approaches to analyzing Supreme Court decision making, this study reveals the inaccuracy of the popular perception that most of the justices merely acted upon a shared, liberal preference for an egalitarian society when they held that racial segregation in public education violates the equal protection clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. A majority of the justices were motivated, instead, by institutional considerations, including a recognition of the need to present a united front in such a controversial case, a sense that the Court had a significant role to play in international affairs during the Cold War, and a belief that the Court had an important mission to counter racial injustice in American politics.

A Storm over This Court demonstrates that the infusion of justices’ personal policy preferences into the abstract language of the Constitution is not the only alternative to an originalist approach to constitutional interpretation. Ultimately, Hockett concludes that the justices' decisions in Brown resist any single, elegant explanation. To fully explain this watershed decision—and, by implication, others—it is necessary to employ a range of approaches dictated by the case in question.

View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart

On the way to offering a new analysis of the basis of the Supreme Court’s iconic decision in Brown v. Board of Education, Jeffrey Hockett critiques an array of theories that have arisen to explain it and Supreme Court decision making generally. Drawing upon justices’ books, articles, correspondence, memoranda, and draft opinions, A Storm over This Court demonstrates that the puzzle of Brown’s basis cannot be explained by any one theory.

Borrowing insights from numerous approaches to analyzing Supreme Court decision making, this study reveals the inaccuracy of the popular perception that most of the justices merely acted upon a shared, liberal preference for an egalitarian society when they held that racial segregation in public education violates the equal protection clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. A majority of the justices were motivated, instead, by institutional considerations, including a recognition of the need to present a united front in such a controversial case, a sense that the Court had a significant role to play in international affairs during the Cold War, and a belief that the Court had an important mission to counter racial injustice in American politics.

A Storm over This Court demonstrates that the infusion of justices’ personal policy preferences into the abstract language of the Constitution is not the only alternative to an originalist approach to constitutional interpretation. Ultimately, Hockett concludes that the justices' decisions in Brown resist any single, elegant explanation. To fully explain this watershed decision—and, by implication, others—it is necessary to employ a range of approaches dictated by the case in question.

More books from University of Virginia Press

Cover of the book Performatively Speaking by Jeffrey D. Hockett
Cover of the book Citizens of a Common Intellectual Homeland by Jeffrey D. Hockett
Cover of the book A World of Their Own by Jeffrey D. Hockett
Cover of the book Polygraphies by Jeffrey D. Hockett
Cover of the book Civil War Talks by Jeffrey D. Hockett
Cover of the book A Passion for the Past by Jeffrey D. Hockett
Cover of the book Imitation Nation by Jeffrey D. Hockett
Cover of the book Skyscraper Gothic by Jeffrey D. Hockett
Cover of the book The Key to the Door by Jeffrey D. Hockett
Cover of the book Confederate Visions by Jeffrey D. Hockett
Cover of the book American Abolitionism by Jeffrey D. Hockett
Cover of the book Culture and Liberty in the Age of the American Revolution by Jeffrey D. Hockett
Cover of the book Patriots, Prostitutes, and Spies by Jeffrey D. Hockett
Cover of the book The Road to Black Ned's Forge by Jeffrey D. Hockett
Cover of the book Different Shades of Green by Jeffrey D. Hockett
We use our own "cookies" and third party cookies to improve services and to see statistical information. By using this website, you agree to our Privacy Policy