A whole affects its parts?

Bottom-up and top-down changes reconsidered

Nonfiction, Religion & Spirituality, Philosophy
Cover of the book A whole affects its parts? by Bernd Lindemann, invoco-Verlag
View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart
Author: Bernd Lindemann ISBN: 9783938165423
Publisher: invoco-Verlag Publication: April 28, 2015
Imprint: Language: English
Author: Bernd Lindemann
ISBN: 9783938165423
Publisher: invoco-Verlag
Publication: April 28, 2015
Imprint:
Language: English
Can a whole change its components top-down? With a whole constituted of components (or parts), top-down changes should originate at the whole (assigned to system level n) and affect the components at the level below (level n-1, “the bottom”). Top-down experiments search for such changes in natural mechanisms. They require (a) primary interaction of a peer object with the mechanism as a whole, which is (b) followed or accompanied by a change among its components. It is often claimed that such experiments or observations (of swarm behaviour, for instance) have shown that a whole can indeed change the properties of its parts. However, all the top-down experiments and observations considered here turn out to have alternative explanations of the bottom-bottom plus bottom-up type. To account for this disconcerting result, I argue that a constituted whole necessarily depends in existence and all properties on its components and their relations and only on them. This restriction implies that, contrary to expectation, a constituted whole (a) cannot be subjected to a not-constitutive top-top change. Nor can it then (b) effect a top-down inverse-constitutive change, as the constitutive relation of mechanisms is shown to be asymmetric (bottom-up only). (Proof included.) Nor can the whole (c) effect a top-down causal change, as a whole cannot encounter the components, which it inseparably contains, for interlevel interaction. For these reasons mutual manipulability of whole and components of mechanisms, which the literature claimed repeatedly, is not possible, top-down changes directed from whole to components remain elusive in theory and practice. Related issues, foremost the nature of constituted wholes and the nature of system levels, are discussed.
View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart
Can a whole change its components top-down? With a whole constituted of components (or parts), top-down changes should originate at the whole (assigned to system level n) and affect the components at the level below (level n-1, “the bottom”). Top-down experiments search for such changes in natural mechanisms. They require (a) primary interaction of a peer object with the mechanism as a whole, which is (b) followed or accompanied by a change among its components. It is often claimed that such experiments or observations (of swarm behaviour, for instance) have shown that a whole can indeed change the properties of its parts. However, all the top-down experiments and observations considered here turn out to have alternative explanations of the bottom-bottom plus bottom-up type. To account for this disconcerting result, I argue that a constituted whole necessarily depends in existence and all properties on its components and their relations and only on them. This restriction implies that, contrary to expectation, a constituted whole (a) cannot be subjected to a not-constitutive top-top change. Nor can it then (b) effect a top-down inverse-constitutive change, as the constitutive relation of mechanisms is shown to be asymmetric (bottom-up only). (Proof included.) Nor can the whole (c) effect a top-down causal change, as a whole cannot encounter the components, which it inseparably contains, for interlevel interaction. For these reasons mutual manipulability of whole and components of mechanisms, which the literature claimed repeatedly, is not possible, top-down changes directed from whole to components remain elusive in theory and practice. Related issues, foremost the nature of constituted wholes and the nature of system levels, are discussed.

More books from Philosophy

Cover of the book The Incorporeal by Bernd Lindemann
Cover of the book Wounded By Christianity by Bernd Lindemann
Cover of the book Rudolf Steiner und die Waldorfpädagogik by Bernd Lindemann
Cover of the book Ausgewählte Schriften zur Geschichtsphilosophie, Ethik und Politik by Bernd Lindemann
Cover of the book Matériaux philosophiques et scientifiques pour un matérialisme contemporain by Bernd Lindemann
Cover of the book Discours de Métaphysique by Bernd Lindemann
Cover of the book Eroi della politica by Bernd Lindemann
Cover of the book Evolution of the Brain: Creation of the Self by Bernd Lindemann
Cover of the book Le Banquet, ou de l'amour by Bernd Lindemann
Cover of the book Some Considerations of the Consequences of the Lowering of Interest and the Raising of the Value of Money by Bernd Lindemann
Cover of the book Das Abenteuer. Der Freund by Bernd Lindemann
Cover of the book Dispositions by Bernd Lindemann
Cover of the book Classic Philosophy: Eight Books By Arthur Schopenhauer In A Single File by Bernd Lindemann
Cover of the book A Brief History of Thought by Bernd Lindemann
Cover of the book Ataraxia: The Elixir of Epicurus: Teachings of Epicurus for Freedom from Fear by Bernd Lindemann
We use our own "cookies" and third party cookies to improve services and to see statistical information. By using this website, you agree to our Privacy Policy