An Entrenched Legacy

How the New Deal Constitutional Revolution Continues to Shape the Role of the Supreme Court

Nonfiction, Reference & Language, Law, Federal Jurisdiction, Constitutional, Social & Cultural Studies, Political Science
Cover of the book An Entrenched Legacy by Patrick M. Garry, Penn State University Press
View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart
Author: Patrick M. Garry ISBN: 9780271075617
Publisher: Penn State University Press Publication: December 13, 2007
Imprint: Penn State University Press Language: English
Author: Patrick M. Garry
ISBN: 9780271075617
Publisher: Penn State University Press
Publication: December 13, 2007
Imprint: Penn State University Press
Language: English

An Entrenched Legacy takes a fresh look at the role of the Supreme Court in our modern constitutional system. Although criticisms of judicial power today often attribute its rise to the activism of justices seeking to advance particular political ideologies, Patrick Garry argues instead that the Supreme Court’s power has grown mainly because of certain constitutional decisions during the New Deal era that initially seemed to portend a lessening of the Court’s power.

When the Court retreated from enforcing separation of powers and federalism as the twin structural protections for individual liberty in the face of FDR’s New Deal agenda, it was inevitably drawn into an alternative approach, substantive due process, as a means for protecting individual rights. This has led to many controversial judicial rulings, particularly regarding the recognition and enforcement of privacy rights. It has also led to the mistaken belief that the judiciary serves as the only protection of liberty and that an inherent conflict exists between individual liberty and majoritarian rule. Moreover, because the Court has assumed sole responsibility for preserving liberty, the whole area of individual rights has become highly centralized. As Garry argues, individual rights have been placed exclusively under judicial jurisdiction not because of anything the Constitution commands, but because of the constitutional compromise of the New Deal.

During the Rehnquist era, the Court tried to reinvigorate the constitutional doctrine of federalism by strengthening certain powers of the states. But, according to Garry, this effort only went halfway toward a true revival of federalism, since the Court continued to rely on judicially enforced individual rights for the protection of liberty. A more comprehensive reform would require a return to the earlier reliance on both federalism and separation of powers as structural devices for protecting liberty. Such reform, as Garry notes, would also help revitalize the role of legislatures in our democratic system.

View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart

An Entrenched Legacy takes a fresh look at the role of the Supreme Court in our modern constitutional system. Although criticisms of judicial power today often attribute its rise to the activism of justices seeking to advance particular political ideologies, Patrick Garry argues instead that the Supreme Court’s power has grown mainly because of certain constitutional decisions during the New Deal era that initially seemed to portend a lessening of the Court’s power.

When the Court retreated from enforcing separation of powers and federalism as the twin structural protections for individual liberty in the face of FDR’s New Deal agenda, it was inevitably drawn into an alternative approach, substantive due process, as a means for protecting individual rights. This has led to many controversial judicial rulings, particularly regarding the recognition and enforcement of privacy rights. It has also led to the mistaken belief that the judiciary serves as the only protection of liberty and that an inherent conflict exists between individual liberty and majoritarian rule. Moreover, because the Court has assumed sole responsibility for preserving liberty, the whole area of individual rights has become highly centralized. As Garry argues, individual rights have been placed exclusively under judicial jurisdiction not because of anything the Constitution commands, but because of the constitutional compromise of the New Deal.

During the Rehnquist era, the Court tried to reinvigorate the constitutional doctrine of federalism by strengthening certain powers of the states. But, according to Garry, this effort only went halfway toward a true revival of federalism, since the Court continued to rely on judicially enforced individual rights for the protection of liberty. A more comprehensive reform would require a return to the earlier reliance on both federalism and separation of powers as structural devices for protecting liberty. Such reform, as Garry notes, would also help revitalize the role of legislatures in our democratic system.

More books from Penn State University Press

Cover of the book Posthumous America by Patrick M. Garry
Cover of the book Reorganizing Popular Politics by Patrick M. Garry
Cover of the book The Sacrament of Penance and Religious Life in Golden Age Spain by Patrick M. Garry
Cover of the book Medical Caregiving and Identity in Pennsylvania's Anthracite Region, 1880–2000 by Patrick M. Garry
Cover of the book Church and Estate by Patrick M. Garry
Cover of the book Ernest Hemingway by Patrick M. Garry
Cover of the book Neoliberalism, Accountability, and Reform Failures in Emerging Markets by Patrick M. Garry
Cover of the book Landscape into Eco Art by Patrick M. Garry
Cover of the book The Problems and Promise of Commercial Society by Patrick M. Garry
Cover of the book The Enlightened Joseph Priestley by Patrick M. Garry
Cover of the book Borderline Exegesis by Patrick M. Garry
Cover of the book Taking Turns by Patrick M. Garry
Cover of the book The House of the Black Ring by Patrick M. Garry
Cover of the book International Migration in Cuba by Patrick M. Garry
Cover of the book Why Budgets Matter by Patrick M. Garry
We use our own "cookies" and third party cookies to improve services and to see statistical information. By using this website, you agree to our Privacy Policy