Explanation and Progress in Security Studies

Bridging Theoretical Divides in International Relations

Nonfiction, Social & Cultural Studies, Political Science, International, International Relations
Cover of the book Explanation and Progress in Security Studies by Fred Chernoff, Stanford University Press
View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart
Author: Fred Chernoff ISBN: 9780804792295
Publisher: Stanford University Press Publication: August 20, 2014
Imprint: Stanford Security Studies Language: English
Author: Fred Chernoff
ISBN: 9780804792295
Publisher: Stanford University Press
Publication: August 20, 2014
Imprint: Stanford Security Studies
Language: English

Explanation and Progress in Security Studies asks why Security Studies, as a central area of International Relations, has not experienced scientific progress in the way natural sciences have—and answers by arguing that the underlying reason is that scholars in Security Studies have advanced a range of different notions of "explanation" or different criteria of "explanatory superiority" to show that their positions are better than rival positions. To demonstrate this, the author engages in in-depth content analysis of the generally recognized exemplars of explanation and explanatory superiority in three of the core debates in the disciplines: Why do states pursue policies of nuclear proliferation? Why do states choose to form the alliances they do? And why do liberal democratic states behave the way they do toward other liberal democracies? The book reveals that authors in the debates that have shown the most progress use similar criteria in arguing for and against the key explanations. In the nuclear proliferation debate, there is wide divergence in the criteria the most visible authors use, and there is wide divergence in the explanations offered. In the alliance formation/balance-of-power debate, there is some overlap of criteria the most important authors use, and there has been some limited movement toward consensus. In the democratic peace debate there has been much more overlap of criteria the most prominent authors use, and there is agreement on both some positive and negative conclusions.

View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart

Explanation and Progress in Security Studies asks why Security Studies, as a central area of International Relations, has not experienced scientific progress in the way natural sciences have—and answers by arguing that the underlying reason is that scholars in Security Studies have advanced a range of different notions of "explanation" or different criteria of "explanatory superiority" to show that their positions are better than rival positions. To demonstrate this, the author engages in in-depth content analysis of the generally recognized exemplars of explanation and explanatory superiority in three of the core debates in the disciplines: Why do states pursue policies of nuclear proliferation? Why do states choose to form the alliances they do? And why do liberal democratic states behave the way they do toward other liberal democracies? The book reveals that authors in the debates that have shown the most progress use similar criteria in arguing for and against the key explanations. In the nuclear proliferation debate, there is wide divergence in the criteria the most visible authors use, and there is wide divergence in the explanations offered. In the alliance formation/balance-of-power debate, there is some overlap of criteria the most important authors use, and there has been some limited movement toward consensus. In the democratic peace debate there has been much more overlap of criteria the most prominent authors use, and there is agreement on both some positive and negative conclusions.

More books from Stanford University Press

Cover of the book Minority Business Success by Fred Chernoff
Cover of the book Making Their Place by Fred Chernoff
Cover of the book A Political History of National Citizenship and Identity in Italy, 1861–1950 by Fred Chernoff
Cover of the book Managing Multiculturalism by Fred Chernoff
Cover of the book Coercive Concern by Fred Chernoff
Cover of the book Contentious Spirits by Fred Chernoff
Cover of the book The Soul of Design by Fred Chernoff
Cover of the book The Schooled Society by Fred Chernoff
Cover of the book Borrowed Light by Fred Chernoff
Cover of the book Failed Democratization in Prewar Japan by Fred Chernoff
Cover of the book Born Red by Fred Chernoff
Cover of the book The Dragon in the Room by Fred Chernoff
Cover of the book And Then We Work for God by Fred Chernoff
Cover of the book Gulf Security and the U.S. Military by Fred Chernoff
Cover of the book Revolution within the Revolution by Fred Chernoff
We use our own "cookies" and third party cookies to improve services and to see statistical information. By using this website, you agree to our Privacy Policy