Failure In Independent Tactical Command: Napoleon’s Marshals In 1813

Nonfiction, History, Spain & Portugal, France, Military
Cover of the book Failure In Independent Tactical Command: Napoleon’s Marshals In 1813 by Major John M. Keefe, Wagram Press
View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart
Author: Major John M. Keefe ISBN: 9781782899976
Publisher: Wagram Press Publication: November 6, 2015
Imprint: Wagram Press Language: English
Author: Major John M. Keefe
ISBN: 9781782899976
Publisher: Wagram Press
Publication: November 6, 2015
Imprint: Wagram Press
Language: English

This monograph offers a new perspective on an old subject. That is why did Napoleon’s marshals, so successful in corps command, fail when given an independent army command? It examines in detail the defeats of Marshal Nicolas Charles Oudinot at Gross Beeren, Marshal Etienne MacDonald at Katzbach, and Marshal Michel Ney at Dennewitz.

Many authors have speculated why these marshals failed in independent tactical command. They have offered such reasons as lack of talent, lack of guidance from Napoleon or the failure to understand the nature of Napoleonic warfare. While these reasons are valid, they are contributing factors rather than the primary reason for the failure of napoleon’s marshals.

A thorough analysis of Napoleon’s Correspondences for the period 10 August through 8 September 1813 reveals that Napoleon did provide adequate guidance to his subordinate commanders. A detailed study of the actions of all three marshals in both movement to and conduct during battle reveals that they in fact understood the nature of Napoleonic warfare. Certainly lack of talent was not the problem as each had been very successful in combat for twenty-two years. The primary reason that these marshals failed was their inability to command and control their forces. Lack of adequate staffs and an inability to make the intellectual leap from corps to army command proved to be their downfall.

View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart

This monograph offers a new perspective on an old subject. That is why did Napoleon’s marshals, so successful in corps command, fail when given an independent army command? It examines in detail the defeats of Marshal Nicolas Charles Oudinot at Gross Beeren, Marshal Etienne MacDonald at Katzbach, and Marshal Michel Ney at Dennewitz.

Many authors have speculated why these marshals failed in independent tactical command. They have offered such reasons as lack of talent, lack of guidance from Napoleon or the failure to understand the nature of Napoleonic warfare. While these reasons are valid, they are contributing factors rather than the primary reason for the failure of napoleon’s marshals.

A thorough analysis of Napoleon’s Correspondences for the period 10 August through 8 September 1813 reveals that Napoleon did provide adequate guidance to his subordinate commanders. A detailed study of the actions of all three marshals in both movement to and conduct during battle reveals that they in fact understood the nature of Napoleonic warfare. Certainly lack of talent was not the problem as each had been very successful in combat for twenty-two years. The primary reason that these marshals failed was their inability to command and control their forces. Lack of adequate staffs and an inability to make the intellectual leap from corps to army command proved to be their downfall.

More books from Wagram Press

Cover of the book Commentaries on the war in Russia and Germany in 1812 and 1813 by Major John M. Keefe
Cover of the book Memoirs of Constant - First Valet de Chambre to the Emperor. Vol III by Major John M. Keefe
Cover of the book The Political and Military History of the Campaign of Waterloo [Illustrated Edition] by Major John M. Keefe
Cover of the book Memoirs Of The Emperor Napoleon – From Ajaccio To Waterloo, As Soldier, Emperor And Husband – Vol. III by Major John M. Keefe
Cover of the book Memoirs Of The War In Spain, From 1808 To 1814. — Vol. I by Major John M. Keefe
Cover of the book Mes campagnes (1792-1815) - Notes et correspondance du colonel d'artillerie Pion des Loches by Major John M. Keefe
Cover of the book From Midshipman To Field Marshal – Vol. II by Major John M. Keefe
Cover of the book Napoleon In Italy, 1796-1797 by Major John M. Keefe
Cover of the book A History of the Peninsular War, Volume IV December 1810-December 1811 by Major John M. Keefe
Cover of the book Narrative of a forced journey through Spain and France, as a prisoner of war, in the years 1810 to 1814. Vol. I by Major John M. Keefe
Cover of the book Memoirs of British Generals Distinguished in the Peninsular War. Vol. II by Major John M. Keefe
Cover of the book Waterloo Lectures: A Study Of The Campaign Of 1815 [Illustrated - 4th Edition] by Major John M. Keefe
Cover of the book A Circumstantial Narrative Of The Campaign In Russia by Major John M. Keefe
Cover of the book Napoleon's Campaign in Poland, 1806–1807 by Major John M. Keefe
Cover of the book Annals Of The Peninsular Campaigns, From 1808 to 1814—Vol. II by Major John M. Keefe
We use our own "cookies" and third party cookies to improve services and to see statistical information. By using this website, you agree to our Privacy Policy