Historical Truth and Lies About the Past

Reflections on Dewey, Dreyfus, de Man, and Reagan

Nonfiction, History, Reference, Historiography
Cover of the book Historical Truth and Lies About the Past by Alan B. Spitzer, The University of North Carolina Press
View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart
Author: Alan B. Spitzer ISBN: 9780807864692
Publisher: The University of North Carolina Press Publication: November 9, 2000
Imprint: The University of North Carolina Press Language: English
Author: Alan B. Spitzer
ISBN: 9780807864692
Publisher: The University of North Carolina Press
Publication: November 9, 2000
Imprint: The University of North Carolina Press
Language: English

Historians have long struggled with the questions of historical relativism, objectivity, and standards of proof and evidence. Intellectual historian Alan Spitzer focuses on the contradiction between theory and practice by presenting case studies of four politically charged debates about the past: the response to the report of the commission chaired by John Dewey that evaluated the accusations made against Leon Trotsky in the Moscow Purge Trials of 1937, the Dreyfus Affair in turn-of-the-century France, the allegations about the extent and meaning of literary critic Paul de Man's complicity with the German occupation forces in wartime Belgium, and Ronald Reagan's justification for his 1987 visit to a German cemetery where Nazi SS officers are buried. Spitzer's argument centers on the ways in which the authority of 'objective' criteria for historical judgment are introduced in politicized disputes about the past, regardless of the theoretical qualification or repudiation of such standards. The higher the political stakes, the more likely the antagonists are to appeal to generally warranted standards of relevant evidence and rational inference. Spitzer's commentary speaks to issues that transcend the specific content of the four cases he discusses.

View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart

Historians have long struggled with the questions of historical relativism, objectivity, and standards of proof and evidence. Intellectual historian Alan Spitzer focuses on the contradiction between theory and practice by presenting case studies of four politically charged debates about the past: the response to the report of the commission chaired by John Dewey that evaluated the accusations made against Leon Trotsky in the Moscow Purge Trials of 1937, the Dreyfus Affair in turn-of-the-century France, the allegations about the extent and meaning of literary critic Paul de Man's complicity with the German occupation forces in wartime Belgium, and Ronald Reagan's justification for his 1987 visit to a German cemetery where Nazi SS officers are buried. Spitzer's argument centers on the ways in which the authority of 'objective' criteria for historical judgment are introduced in politicized disputes about the past, regardless of the theoretical qualification or repudiation of such standards. The higher the political stakes, the more likely the antagonists are to appeal to generally warranted standards of relevant evidence and rational inference. Spitzer's commentary speaks to issues that transcend the specific content of the four cases he discusses.

More books from The University of North Carolina Press

Cover of the book Economics in the Long Run by Alan B. Spitzer
Cover of the book Christmas in Germany by Alan B. Spitzer
Cover of the book The Wild and the Toxic by Alan B. Spitzer
Cover of the book Game Changers by Alan B. Spitzer
Cover of the book Country Soul by Alan B. Spitzer
Cover of the book The Artistry of Anger by Alan B. Spitzer
Cover of the book The Descent of Darwin by Alan B. Spitzer
Cover of the book Prozac as a Way of Life by Alan B. Spitzer
Cover of the book The Populist Challenge by Alan B. Spitzer
Cover of the book First Fruits of Freedom by Alan B. Spitzer
Cover of the book Beyond Slavery by Alan B. Spitzer
Cover of the book Visions of Power in Cuba by Alan B. Spitzer
Cover of the book The Fruits of Their Labor by Alan B. Spitzer
Cover of the book North Carolina’s Roadside Eateries by Alan B. Spitzer
Cover of the book What Is Veiling? by Alan B. Spitzer
We use our own "cookies" and third party cookies to improve services and to see statistical information. By using this website, you agree to our Privacy Policy