Mechanism, Mentalism and Metamathematics

An Essay on Finitism

Nonfiction, Science & Nature, Science, Other Sciences, Philosophy & Social Aspects, Religion & Spirituality, Philosophy, Mind & Body
Cover of the book Mechanism, Mentalism and Metamathematics by J. Webb, Springer Netherlands
View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart
Author: J. Webb ISBN: 9789401576536
Publisher: Springer Netherlands Publication: March 9, 2013
Imprint: Springer Language: English
Author: J. Webb
ISBN: 9789401576536
Publisher: Springer Netherlands
Publication: March 9, 2013
Imprint: Springer
Language: English

This book grew out of a graduate student paper [261] in which I set down some criticisms of J. R. Lucas' attempt to refute mechanism by means of G6del's theorem. I had made several such abortive attempts myself and had become familiar with their pitfalls, and especially with the double­ edged nature of incompleteness arguments. My original idea was to model the refutation of mechanism on the almost universally accepted G6delian refutation of Hilbert's formalism, but I kept getting stuck on questions of mathematical philosophy which I found myself having to beg. A thorough study of the foundational works of Hilbert and Bernays finally convinced me that I had all too naively and uncritically bought this refutation of formalism. I did indeed discover points of surprisingly close contact between formalism and mechanism, but also that it was possible to under­ mine certain strong arguments against these positions precisely by invok­ ing G6del's and related work. I also began to realize that the Church­ Turing thesis itself is the principal bastion protecting mechanism, and that G6del's work was perhaps the best thing that ever happened to both mechanism and formalism. I pushed these lines of argument in my dis­ sertation with the patient help of my readers, Raymond Nelson and Howard Stein. I would especially like to thank the latter for many valuable criticisms of my dissertation as well as some helpful suggestions for reor­ ganizing it in the direction of the present book.

View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart

This book grew out of a graduate student paper [261] in which I set down some criticisms of J. R. Lucas' attempt to refute mechanism by means of G6del's theorem. I had made several such abortive attempts myself and had become familiar with their pitfalls, and especially with the double­ edged nature of incompleteness arguments. My original idea was to model the refutation of mechanism on the almost universally accepted G6delian refutation of Hilbert's formalism, but I kept getting stuck on questions of mathematical philosophy which I found myself having to beg. A thorough study of the foundational works of Hilbert and Bernays finally convinced me that I had all too naively and uncritically bought this refutation of formalism. I did indeed discover points of surprisingly close contact between formalism and mechanism, but also that it was possible to under­ mine certain strong arguments against these positions precisely by invok­ ing G6del's and related work. I also began to realize that the Church­ Turing thesis itself is the principal bastion protecting mechanism, and that G6del's work was perhaps the best thing that ever happened to both mechanism and formalism. I pushed these lines of argument in my dis­ sertation with the patient help of my readers, Raymond Nelson and Howard Stein. I would especially like to thank the latter for many valuable criticisms of my dissertation as well as some helpful suggestions for reor­ ganizing it in the direction of the present book.

More books from Springer Netherlands

Cover of the book Rescuing Reason by J. Webb
Cover of the book Shakespeare’s Religious Frontier by J. Webb
Cover of the book Self-Evaluation by J. Webb
Cover of the book Naming the Rainbow by J. Webb
Cover of the book Medicine Science and Dreams by J. Webb
Cover of the book Forest Genetics and Sustainability by J. Webb
Cover of the book Spectral Methods in Chemistry and Physics by J. Webb
Cover of the book Climate Change, Climate Science and Economics by J. Webb
Cover of the book Justification and Knowledge by J. Webb
Cover of the book Financing International Organization: The United Nations Budget Process by J. Webb
Cover of the book Dynamics and Vibrations by J. Webb
Cover of the book Actin-based Motility by J. Webb
Cover of the book Methodology of History by J. Webb
Cover of the book The Essence of Manifestation by J. Webb
Cover of the book Ethics, Medical Research, and Medicine by J. Webb
We use our own "cookies" and third party cookies to improve services and to see statistical information. By using this website, you agree to our Privacy Policy