Philosophers in the "Republic"

Plato's Two Paradigms

Nonfiction, Religion & Spirituality, Philosophy, Ancient, Political
Cover of the book Philosophers in the "Republic" by Roslyn Weiss, Cornell University Press
View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart
Author: Roslyn Weiss ISBN: 9780801465611
Publisher: Cornell University Press Publication: August 16, 2012
Imprint: Cornell University Press Language: English
Author: Roslyn Weiss
ISBN: 9780801465611
Publisher: Cornell University Press
Publication: August 16, 2012
Imprint: Cornell University Press
Language: English

In Plato’s Republic Socrates contends that philosophers make the best rulers because only they behold with their mind’s eye the eternal and purely intelligible Forms of the Just, the Noble, and the Good. When, in addition, these men and women are endowed with a vast array of moral, intellectual, and personal virtues and are appropriately educated, surely no one could doubt the wisdom of entrusting to them the governance of cities. Although it is widely—and reasonably—assumed that all the Republic’s philosophers are the same, Roslyn Weiss argues in this boldly original book that the Republic actually contains two distinct and irreconcilable portrayals of the philosopher.

According to Weiss, Plato’s two paradigms of the philosopher are the "philosopher by nature" and the "philosopher by design." Philosophers by design, as the allegory of the Cave vividly shows, must be forcibly dragged from the material world of pleasure to the sublime realm of the intellect, and from there back down again to the "Cave" to rule the beautiful city envisioned by Socrates and his interlocutors. Yet philosophers by nature, described earlier in the Republic, are distinguished by their natural yearning to encounter the transcendent realm of pure Forms, as well as by a willingness to serve others—at least under appropriate circumstances. In contrast to both sets of philosophers stands Socrates, who represents a third paradigm, one, however, that is no more than hinted at in the Republic. As a man who not only loves "what is" but is also utterly devoted to the justice of others—even at great personal cost—Socrates surpasses both the philosophers by design and the philosophers by nature. By shedding light on an aspect of the Republic that has escaped notice, Weiss’s new interpretation will challenge Plato scholars to revisit their assumptions about Plato’s moral and political philosophy.

View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart

In Plato’s Republic Socrates contends that philosophers make the best rulers because only they behold with their mind’s eye the eternal and purely intelligible Forms of the Just, the Noble, and the Good. When, in addition, these men and women are endowed with a vast array of moral, intellectual, and personal virtues and are appropriately educated, surely no one could doubt the wisdom of entrusting to them the governance of cities. Although it is widely—and reasonably—assumed that all the Republic’s philosophers are the same, Roslyn Weiss argues in this boldly original book that the Republic actually contains two distinct and irreconcilable portrayals of the philosopher.

According to Weiss, Plato’s two paradigms of the philosopher are the "philosopher by nature" and the "philosopher by design." Philosophers by design, as the allegory of the Cave vividly shows, must be forcibly dragged from the material world of pleasure to the sublime realm of the intellect, and from there back down again to the "Cave" to rule the beautiful city envisioned by Socrates and his interlocutors. Yet philosophers by nature, described earlier in the Republic, are distinguished by their natural yearning to encounter the transcendent realm of pure Forms, as well as by a willingness to serve others—at least under appropriate circumstances. In contrast to both sets of philosophers stands Socrates, who represents a third paradigm, one, however, that is no more than hinted at in the Republic. As a man who not only loves "what is" but is also utterly devoted to the justice of others—even at great personal cost—Socrates surpasses both the philosophers by design and the philosophers by nature. By shedding light on an aspect of the Republic that has escaped notice, Weiss’s new interpretation will challenge Plato scholars to revisit their assumptions about Plato’s moral and political philosophy.

More books from Cornell University Press

Cover of the book Decadent Genealogies by Roslyn Weiss
Cover of the book Juki Girls, Good Girls by Roslyn Weiss
Cover of the book "Strong of Body, Brave and Noble" by Roslyn Weiss
Cover of the book Our Frontier Is the World by Roslyn Weiss
Cover of the book Insurgency Trap by Roslyn Weiss
Cover of the book The Changing Face of Medicine by Roslyn Weiss
Cover of the book Religion on the Battlefield by Roslyn Weiss
Cover of the book Love's Wounds by Roslyn Weiss
Cover of the book Broad Is My Native Land by Roslyn Weiss
Cover of the book Activists in City Hall by Roslyn Weiss
Cover of the book Frontiers of Fear by Roslyn Weiss
Cover of the book Building China by Roslyn Weiss
Cover of the book Making the Unipolar Moment by Roslyn Weiss
Cover of the book The Sephardic Frontier by Roslyn Weiss
Cover of the book The Brown Recluse Spider by Roslyn Weiss
We use our own "cookies" and third party cookies to improve services and to see statistical information. By using this website, you agree to our Privacy Policy