Sign of Pathology

U.S. Medical Rhetoric on Abortion, 1800s–1960s

Nonfiction, Reference & Language, Language Arts, Public Speaking, Rhetoric, History, Americas, United States, 20th Century
Cover of the book Sign of Pathology by Nathan Stormer, Penn State University Press
View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart
Author: Nathan Stormer ISBN: 9780271066905
Publisher: Penn State University Press Publication: April 8, 2015
Imprint: Penn State University Press Language: English
Author: Nathan Stormer
ISBN: 9780271066905
Publisher: Penn State University Press
Publication: April 8, 2015
Imprint: Penn State University Press
Language: English

Much of the political polarization that grips the United States is rooted in the so-called culture wars, and no topic defines this conflict better than the often contentious and sometimes violent debate over abortion rights. In Sign of Pathology, Nathan Stormer reframes our understanding of this conflict by examining the medical literature on abortion from the 1800s to the 1960s.

Often framed as an argument over a right to choose versus a right to life, our current understanding of this conflict is as a contest over who has the better position on reproductive biology. Against this view, Sign of Pathology argues that, as it became a medical problem, abortion also became a template, more generally, for struggling with how to live—far exceeding discussions of the merits of providing abortions or how to care for patients. Abortion practices (and all the legal, moral, and ideological entanglements thereof) have rested firmly at the center of debate over many fundamental institutions and concepts—namely, the individual, the family, the state, human rights, and, indeed, the human. Medical rhetoric, then, was decisive in cultivating abortion as a mode of cultural critique, even weaponizing it for discursive conflict on these important subjects, although the goal of the medical practice of abortion has never been to establish this kind of struggle. Stormer argues that the medical discourse of abortion physicians transformed the state of abortion into an indicator that the culture was ill, attacking itself during and through pregnancy in a wrongheaded attempt to cope with reproduction.

View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart

Much of the political polarization that grips the United States is rooted in the so-called culture wars, and no topic defines this conflict better than the often contentious and sometimes violent debate over abortion rights. In Sign of Pathology, Nathan Stormer reframes our understanding of this conflict by examining the medical literature on abortion from the 1800s to the 1960s.

Often framed as an argument over a right to choose versus a right to life, our current understanding of this conflict is as a contest over who has the better position on reproductive biology. Against this view, Sign of Pathology argues that, as it became a medical problem, abortion also became a template, more generally, for struggling with how to live—far exceeding discussions of the merits of providing abortions or how to care for patients. Abortion practices (and all the legal, moral, and ideological entanglements thereof) have rested firmly at the center of debate over many fundamental institutions and concepts—namely, the individual, the family, the state, human rights, and, indeed, the human. Medical rhetoric, then, was decisive in cultivating abortion as a mode of cultural critique, even weaponizing it for discursive conflict on these important subjects, although the goal of the medical practice of abortion has never been to establish this kind of struggle. Stormer argues that the medical discourse of abortion physicians transformed the state of abortion into an indicator that the culture was ill, attacking itself during and through pregnancy in a wrongheaded attempt to cope with reproduction.

More books from Penn State University Press

Cover of the book Evan Pugh’s Penn State by Nathan Stormer
Cover of the book London Art Worlds by Nathan Stormer
Cover of the book Consensus and Debate in Salazar's Portugal by Nathan Stormer
Cover of the book Voting Deliberatively by Nathan Stormer
Cover of the book The Spiritual Vision of Frank Buchman by Nathan Stormer
Cover of the book The Anglican Communion at a Crossroads by Nathan Stormer
Cover of the book The Warsaw Ghetto in American Art and Culture by Nathan Stormer
Cover of the book Where Honeybees Thrive by Nathan Stormer
Cover of the book Citizens in a Strange Land by Nathan Stormer
Cover of the book Feudal America by Nathan Stormer
Cover of the book Invading Colombia by Nathan Stormer
Cover of the book The Illusion of Civil Society by Nathan Stormer
Cover of the book Conceiving a Nation by Nathan Stormer
Cover of the book The Fourth Enemy by Nathan Stormer
Cover of the book Reality’s Fugue by Nathan Stormer
We use our own "cookies" and third party cookies to improve services and to see statistical information. By using this website, you agree to our Privacy Policy