The Sherlock Effect

How Forensic Doctors and Investigators Disastrously Reason Like the Great Detective

Nonfiction, Reference & Language, Law, Forensic Science, Criminal law
Cover of the book The Sherlock Effect by Thomas W. Young, Taylor and Francis
View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart
Author: Thomas W. Young ISBN: 9781351113816
Publisher: Taylor and Francis Publication: April 20, 2018
Imprint: CRC Press Language: English
Author: Thomas W. Young
ISBN: 9781351113816
Publisher: Taylor and Francis
Publication: April 20, 2018
Imprint: CRC Press
Language: English

Forensic science is in crisis and at a cross-roads. Movies and television dramas depict forensic heroes with high-tech tools and dazzling intellects who—inside an hour, notwithstanding commercials—piece together past-event puzzles from crime scenes and autopsies.  Likewise, Sherlock Holmes—the iconic fictional detective, and the invention of forensic doctor Sir Arthur Conan Doyle—is held up as a paragon of forensic and scientific inspiration—does not "reason forward" as most people do, but "reasons backwards." Put more plainly, rather than learning the train of events and seeing whether the resultant clues match those events, Holmes determines what happened in the past by looking at the clues.  Impressive and infallible as this technique appears to be—it must be recognized that infallibility lies only in works of fiction. Reasoning backward does not work in real life: reality is far less tidy. 

In courtrooms everywhere, innocent people pay the price of life imitating art, of science following detective fiction.  In particular, this book looks at the long and disastrous shadow cast by that icon of deductive reasoning, Sherlock Holmes.

In The Sherlock Effect, author Dr. Thomas W. Young shows why this Sherlock-Holmes-style reasoning does not work and, furthermore, how it can—and has led—to wrongful convictions. Dr. Alan Moritz, one of the early pioneers of forensic pathology in the United States, warned his colleagues in the 1950’s about making the Sherlock Holmes error.  Little did Moritz realize how widespread the problem would eventually become, involving physicians in all other specialties of medicine and not just forensic pathologists.  Dr. Young traces back how this situation evolved, looking back over the history of forensic medicine, revealing the chilling degree to which forensic experts fail us every day. 

While Dr. Young did not want to be the one to write this book, he has felt compelled in the interest of science and truth. This book is measured, well-reasoned, accessible, insightful, and—above all—compelling. As such, it is a must-read treatise for forensic doctors, forensic practitioners and students, judges, lawyers adjudicating cases in court, and anyone with an interest in forensic science.

View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart

Forensic science is in crisis and at a cross-roads. Movies and television dramas depict forensic heroes with high-tech tools and dazzling intellects who—inside an hour, notwithstanding commercials—piece together past-event puzzles from crime scenes and autopsies.  Likewise, Sherlock Holmes—the iconic fictional detective, and the invention of forensic doctor Sir Arthur Conan Doyle—is held up as a paragon of forensic and scientific inspiration—does not "reason forward" as most people do, but "reasons backwards." Put more plainly, rather than learning the train of events and seeing whether the resultant clues match those events, Holmes determines what happened in the past by looking at the clues.  Impressive and infallible as this technique appears to be—it must be recognized that infallibility lies only in works of fiction. Reasoning backward does not work in real life: reality is far less tidy. 

In courtrooms everywhere, innocent people pay the price of life imitating art, of science following detective fiction.  In particular, this book looks at the long and disastrous shadow cast by that icon of deductive reasoning, Sherlock Holmes.

In The Sherlock Effect, author Dr. Thomas W. Young shows why this Sherlock-Holmes-style reasoning does not work and, furthermore, how it can—and has led—to wrongful convictions. Dr. Alan Moritz, one of the early pioneers of forensic pathology in the United States, warned his colleagues in the 1950’s about making the Sherlock Holmes error.  Little did Moritz realize how widespread the problem would eventually become, involving physicians in all other specialties of medicine and not just forensic pathologists.  Dr. Young traces back how this situation evolved, looking back over the history of forensic medicine, revealing the chilling degree to which forensic experts fail us every day. 

While Dr. Young did not want to be the one to write this book, he has felt compelled in the interest of science and truth. This book is measured, well-reasoned, accessible, insightful, and—above all—compelling. As such, it is a must-read treatise for forensic doctors, forensic practitioners and students, judges, lawyers adjudicating cases in court, and anyone with an interest in forensic science.

More books from Taylor and Francis

Cover of the book Classic Cases in Neuropsychology, Volume II by Thomas W. Young
Cover of the book Challenging Authoritarianism in Mexico by Thomas W. Young
Cover of the book The Mummy's Curse by Thomas W. Young
Cover of the book Consultancy and Innovation by Thomas W. Young
Cover of the book The Observation of Savage Peoples by Thomas W. Young
Cover of the book Political Ecology of Tourism by Thomas W. Young
Cover of the book Dark Tourism and Place Identity by Thomas W. Young
Cover of the book New York and the First World War by Thomas W. Young
Cover of the book Violence and American Cinema by Thomas W. Young
Cover of the book Post-Communist Aesthetics by Thomas W. Young
Cover of the book Psychotherapy and the Everyday Life by Thomas W. Young
Cover of the book Making Sense of Social Development by Thomas W. Young
Cover of the book Economic Ideas and Government Policy by Thomas W. Young
Cover of the book Crime and Justice since 1750 by Thomas W. Young
Cover of the book The Routledge Companion to International Children's Literature by Thomas W. Young
We use our own "cookies" and third party cookies to improve services and to see statistical information. By using this website, you agree to our Privacy Policy