Universal Jurisdiction in International Criminal Law

The Debate and the Battle for Hegemony

Nonfiction, Reference & Language, Law, International, Criminal law
Cover of the book Universal Jurisdiction in International Criminal Law by Aisling O'Sullivan, Taylor and Francis
View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart
Author: Aisling O'Sullivan ISBN: 9781317301202
Publisher: Taylor and Francis Publication: February 3, 2017
Imprint: Routledge Language: English
Author: Aisling O'Sullivan
ISBN: 9781317301202
Publisher: Taylor and Francis
Publication: February 3, 2017
Imprint: Routledge
Language: English

With the sensational arrest of former Chilean dictator Augusto Pinochet in 1998, the rise to prominence of universal jurisdiction over crimes against international law seemed to be assured. The arrest of Pinochet and the ensuing proceedings before the UK courts brought universal jurisdiction into the foreground of the "fight against impunity" and the principle was read as an important complementary mechanism for international justice –one that could offer justice to victims denied an avenue by the limited jurisdiction of international criminal tribunals. Yet by the time of the International Court of Justice’s Arrest Warrant judgment four years later, the picture looked much bleaker and the principle was being read as a potential tool for politically motivated trials.

This book explores the debate over universal jurisdiction in international criminal law, aiming to unpack a practice in which international lawyers continue to disagree over the concept of universal jurisdiction. Using Martti Koskenniemi’s work as a foil, this book exposes the argumentative techniques in operation in national and international adjudication since the 1990s. Drawing on overarching patterns within the debate, Aisling O’Sullivan argues that it is bounded by a tension between contrasting political preferences or positions, labelled as moralist ("ending impunity") and formalist ("avoiding abuse") and she reads the debate as a movement of hegemonic and counter-hegemonic positions that struggle for hegemonic control. However, she draws out how these positions (moralist/formalist) merge into one another and this produces a tendency towards a "middle" position that continues to prefer a particular preference (moralist or formalist). Aisling O’Sullivan then traces the transformation towards this tendency that reflects an internal split among international lawyers between building a utopia ("court of humanity") and recognizing its impossibility of being realized.

View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart

With the sensational arrest of former Chilean dictator Augusto Pinochet in 1998, the rise to prominence of universal jurisdiction over crimes against international law seemed to be assured. The arrest of Pinochet and the ensuing proceedings before the UK courts brought universal jurisdiction into the foreground of the "fight against impunity" and the principle was read as an important complementary mechanism for international justice –one that could offer justice to victims denied an avenue by the limited jurisdiction of international criminal tribunals. Yet by the time of the International Court of Justice’s Arrest Warrant judgment four years later, the picture looked much bleaker and the principle was being read as a potential tool for politically motivated trials.

This book explores the debate over universal jurisdiction in international criminal law, aiming to unpack a practice in which international lawyers continue to disagree over the concept of universal jurisdiction. Using Martti Koskenniemi’s work as a foil, this book exposes the argumentative techniques in operation in national and international adjudication since the 1990s. Drawing on overarching patterns within the debate, Aisling O’Sullivan argues that it is bounded by a tension between contrasting political preferences or positions, labelled as moralist ("ending impunity") and formalist ("avoiding abuse") and she reads the debate as a movement of hegemonic and counter-hegemonic positions that struggle for hegemonic control. However, she draws out how these positions (moralist/formalist) merge into one another and this produces a tendency towards a "middle" position that continues to prefer a particular preference (moralist or formalist). Aisling O’Sullivan then traces the transformation towards this tendency that reflects an internal split among international lawyers between building a utopia ("court of humanity") and recognizing its impossibility of being realized.

More books from Taylor and Francis

Cover of the book Race and Gender in the Making of an African American Literary Tradition by Aisling O'Sullivan
Cover of the book Muslims and Crusaders by Aisling O'Sullivan
Cover of the book Russian Foreign Policy under Dmitry Medvedev, 2008-2012 by Aisling O'Sullivan
Cover of the book Fundamental Legal Conceptions As Applied in Judicial Reasoning by Wesley Newcomb Hohfeld by Aisling O'Sullivan
Cover of the book Intergenerational Relationships by Aisling O'Sullivan
Cover of the book Roberto Busa, S. J., and the Emergence of Humanities Computing by Aisling O'Sullivan
Cover of the book Violations of Trust by Aisling O'Sullivan
Cover of the book Between Humanitarianism and Evangelism in Faith-based Organisations by Aisling O'Sullivan
Cover of the book The Birth Of The Family by Aisling O'Sullivan
Cover of the book Nazi Germany and Imperial Japan by Aisling O'Sullivan
Cover of the book Legal Regulation of British Company Accounts 1836-1900 (RLE Accounting) by Aisling O'Sullivan
Cover of the book The Statistical Method in Economics and Political Science by Aisling O'Sullivan
Cover of the book Disorienting Sexuality by Aisling O'Sullivan
Cover of the book The Global and Regional in China's Nation-Formation by Aisling O'Sullivan
Cover of the book International Retailing Plans and Strategies in Asia by Aisling O'Sullivan
We use our own "cookies" and third party cookies to improve services and to see statistical information. By using this website, you agree to our Privacy Policy